Plossl vs Kellner Eyepieces: Which Is The Best?
I have used both Kellner & Plossl eyepieces and a few others, and I can tell you that they all are quite different from each other in terms of the quality of the image that they produce.
In this article, we will only focus on the differences between Plossl and Kellner eyepieces.
Table Of Contents
Plossl vs Kellner
Kellner eyepieces have 3 lenses cemented together and have a 35-50 degree field of view. They have decent eye relief and little curvature of field. Plossl eyepieces have 4 lenses that are paired in two doublets. They have a 50-56 degrees field of view, better eye relief, and cost more than Kellners.
In stargazing, eyepieces are as important as telescopes are. Choosing the most appropriate can completely change your experience in using telescopes. Poorly chosen eyepiece might give you poor experience and sometimes even make stargazing difficult.
So I sincerely hope that this article helps you understand the similarities and differences between Plossl and Kellner eyepieces so that you can an informed decision and choose the best one for yourself.
Later in the article, I will also give my top recommendations for both the best Kellner as well as the best Plossl eyepieces.
Kellner eyepieces were first designed by Carl Kellner in 1849.
Kellner eyepieces use three glass elements in two groups to minimize color fringing.
The design uses a planoconvex, two cemented-element eye lens and a large convex field lens.
However, some lateral color error is apparent when looking at bright subjects, such as Jupiter or Venus, against a dark sky.
These are considered to be the least expensive eyepieces for serious astronomy and are offered in focal lengths from about 6mm to 40mm.
These eyepieces have about 35 to 50 degrees apparent fields of view and reasonable eye relief, though quite short for high magnifications.
Kellner eyepieces work perfectly with small and medium-sized telescopes.
They have good center sharpness but exhibit some field curvature and astigmatism.
Edge sharpness is just satisfactory, nothing to boast about, as is the apparent field of view. They are most useful in medium and longer focal lengths for terrestrial, planetary, and lunar viewing.
Major telescope brands such as Celestron supplies Kellner eyepieces with their r least expensive telescopes and still may.
An Austrian inventor Georg Simon Plossl came up with the Plossl eyepiece design in 1860.
This design features 4 lenses that are paired in two close-set doublets for the eye lens and the field lens.
This four-element Plössl design is the most popular eyepiece optical design that gives you excellent image quality, good eye relief, and a 50 to 56 degrees apparent field of view. High-quality Plössl eyepieces provide high contrast and sharpness across the entire field of view.
The Plossl design has become the mainstay of the modern ocular business and probably represents the best value in terms of performance and price, especially in medium and long focal lengths.
Plossls cost a bit more than the Kellners as Plossls are expensive to manufacture because they require good optical glass and precisely matched concave and convex doublet surfaces to prevent internal reflections.
That said, I should also tell you that not all Plossls are created equal.
Inexpensive Plossls that are manufactured using low-quality lenses are susceptible to internal reflections when viewing bright objects at high magnification.
These low-quality Plossls lack an internally blackened lens barrel with thread baffles and blackened lens edges and sophisticated anti-reflection multi-coatings, all of which are a necessity to produce an excellent image.
If well made, Plossls are bright, with good contrast, and a flat field, and excellent sharpness. Their eye relief is limited to about 70-80% of their focal length.
Plossls are available from many suppliers in a wide range of focal lengths in 1.25″ and 2″ sizes.
The focal length range for 1.25″ Plossls is about 6mm to 45mm.
Plossls provide very good eye relief for eyeglass wearers in focal lengths of about 25mm and longer.
Non-eyeglass wearers can usually tolerate Plossls as short as about 10-12mm before their eyelashes start brushing the ocular lens.
Kellner vs Plossl – What are the differences?
|Number of lenses||3||4|
|Field of view||35-50 degrees||50-56 degrees|
Kellner vs Plossl – Which one is better?
Here’s the short answer – Plossl eyepieces are generally better than Kellner eyepieces, but they also tend to be more expensive.
As I mentioned earlier in the article, not all Plossls are created equal, which simply means that there are good Plossls and then there are bad Plossls.
I must also warn you that some of these bad Plossls may actually turn out to be worse than any run-of-the-mill Kellner.
The quality of a Plossl eyepiece completely depends on the brand and model, so be very careful in our selection.
If you do choose to go with a Plossl eyepiece, I highly recommend spending some extra cash to get yourself a decent good quality branded Plossl eyepiece rather than going for a cheap, generic eyepiece which is a Plossl only for the namesake.
Kellner eyepieces, on the other hand, are generally pretty close to each other in terms of quality so there’s little chance you will get much variance in image definition between brands.
If you are completely new to stargazing, Kellner eyepieces are absolutely fine. As you learn more about astronomy and you gain more experience with time, you may want to move to Plossls or even higher-quality eyepieces.
If you are buying your first telescope, and you are choosing between the telescope that includes a Kellner or a telescope that comes with a Plossl, with all the other specs being similar, pick the telescope that’s offering you the Plossl, even if it’s slightly more expensive.
As long as you take good care of them, Plossls can last you a lifetime, and you will be able to use them with your next telescope if you upgrade at some point.
Best Plossl & Kellner Eyepieces
If you’re looking for Plossl or Kellner eyepieces, here are my top recommendations for each.
All three of my recommendations are actually eyepiece and accessory sets rather than one single eyepiece.
SVBONY Telescope Eyepiece Set
SVBONY Telescope Eyepiece Set comes with 3 Plossl eyepieces and a 2x Barlow lens.
These eyepieces are suitable for observation of nebulae, star clusters, lunar surface & pits, planetary surface and star details, and more. They come with a foldable soft silicone rubber eyecup for the comfort of the observer, and they are suitable for anyone wearing glasses and not wearing glasses.
SVBONY 1.25 inches Kellner Eyepiece Kit
The SVBONY 1.25 inches Kellner Eyepiece Kit comes with three 9mm 17.5mm 25mm, 1.25” eyepieces. The Modified achromatic design features an optical advancement over the traditional Kellner and gives sharp lunar, planetary images. The lenses are multi-coated and have blackened edges and a blackened interior. This would be an excellent choice for budget-conscious amateur stargazers.
Celestron Eyepiece and Filter Accessory Kit
The Celestron Telescope Eyepiece & Filter Accessory Kit is an excellent buy for good quality Plossl oculars. It is an especially good way for the new telescope purchaser to get started with an array of oculars.
his kit includes five Plossl eyepieces that provide a wide range of magnifications on any given telescope, six of the most popular colored planetary filters to enhance the views, a Moon filter that reduces glare from the lunar surface while enhancing contrast, and a 2x Barlow lens which essentially doubles the magnification of any eyepiece used with it.
An included hard aluminum carrying case protects the accessories while custom die-cut foam on the inside cushions them.
If you’re still wondering between a Kellner vs Plossl, my advice to you would be – invest a little extra cash and go for a good quality Plossl. It may very well last you a lifetime and in the long term, you will definitely consider it to be a worthwhile investment.
Although Kellner eyepieces will help you learn a lot in the beginning but soon will realize that you’re missing out on something, and eventually you will be tempted to spend money on another good quality eyepiece.
So save yourself this future unnecessary expense and just buy a Plossl.
- Reflector vs Schmidt-Cassegrain Telescope: 5-Minute Read
- What Is A Barlow Lens For A Telescope? What Does It Do?
- What Is A Computerized GoTo Telescope? Are They Worth The Price?
- Can You Leave A Telescope Outside? 5-Minute Read
- How Much Does A Good Telescope Cost? (Beginner’s Guide)
- How To See Venus Through A Telescope: 5-Minute Read
- How To Choose A Perfect Stargazing Location